Noun: Unions. Opinion: Conflicted.
Noun credit: Jen.
Among the nicer, more conscientious of you, there may be those who were wondering where the Judgmentor hath been these many weeks. Among the rest of you are those who never really noticed the absence but are curious now that the topic has been brought up. And the remaining of you may go back to playing Farmville for all I care.
Where have I been? I’ve been busy. Growing more deeply disenchanted with the world is a time-consuming business, I’ll have you know. I have been off having what little remained of my idealism touched in private parts. I have been occupied with the violation of an entire life philosophy. In short, I have been busy becoming more cynical.
The easy joke here is to laugh a not very slightly supercilious laugh, the way Americans laugh at European people, and ask if that is even possible. Just so you know, there is no faster way to have me get my sanctimony on. Idealism is not vacuous, or silly, or embodied by your Tickle-Me-Elmo approach to life. It is not always graced with beauty but it always has an element of splendor. As if there were virtue in serenity, in canopied buoyancy, in blinding smiles and drawing your mental curtains to screen out the ugly. Who’s more cynical, I ask—me, who had pursued an exquisite chimera, or you, chipper as you were, who never questioned whether the world could be better? Me, who made choices with the faith that the result would direct itself towards a normative path, or you, who made negative decisions by accepting the positive reality? What’s a more cynical statement: “This goddamn fucking sucks” or “That’s ok, it’s just the way things are”? No, this is not me getting defensive, this is me not getting you. Some idealists focus on the positive, some focus on the negative, but none of us find willful ignorance funny. Skepticism is not cynicism, though admittedly it’s a slippery slope.
Chew on that while I climb off my soapbox. Anyway, the point is that the slope turns into an outright freefall down the rabbit hole. I (barely) stand witness to it.
The Judgmentor, in fact, never left. The problem was that my last entry was up for all of two minutes before I took it down—it was too dark, too much, too Tori Amos on downers and pomposity. It’s the space my brain is in right now. For the first time in my career, I am working with unions. For the first time, I am working with those without graduate degrees or suburban upbringings or ambitions that don’t involve winning the lottery. For the first time, I am working with the noble proletariat, the great unwashed masses who struggle mightily against the new feudal system of capitalism, those whose income come from honest labor and not from exploitative ownership of the means of the production they make possible. As vulnerable as they are to abuse and mistreatment, as susceptible as they can be to corporate manipulation, do they not have a right to protection?
Well, yes.
Do they deserve it?
Fuck, no.
But not because they need to pull themselves up by their bootstraps or some such Tory nonsense. I don’t buy into a merit system based on accumulated wealth, it smacks too much of over-simplification chased with malice (hear me, Fox News cocksuckers?). Unions don’t deserve to exist because people fundamentally SUCK and because they don’t stop at protecting the innocent from the exploitation of management. They will grab, snatch and claw at more. Samuel Gompers, leader of American unions and founder of the AF of L, summed up human nature when he said “we do want more, and when it becomes more, we shall still want more.” And voila the suckiness of mankind—this isn’t the innocent organizing against corporate evil, this is a simple case of assholery versus assholery.
And what kind of result can possibly manifest from a war of assholes? Never a good one. Where’s Troy today, after all (or Greece, for that matter)? The distortions to the free market system I’ve witnessed that were direct consequences of the union and their irrational demands have been astounding in scope. Hey, I’m no unadulterated fan of competitive capitalism—but however rickety its operations when left alone, it is fucked upside-down when you introduce a market abortion like a collective bargaining agreement. What you can do, say, suggest, how you can execute, scratch your pits and carry out reasonable business practices is completely hamstrung. There is jockeying and posturing on both sides, each trying to position themselves with perceived advantages. The most charming part about the battle is how very human it can be— arbitrary, irrational, and mean-spirited. Unions will negotiate themselves right out jobs just out of spite. Businesses will resort to any covert maneuver to save a buck. And after all that, management still treats workers like shit. If asked by any of the manual laborers I come into contact with, you better believe I tell them to go union.
And thus my idealism lies gasping for breath on the asphalt, bleeding from the head. Beaten to a pulp by the misled notion that responsible self-interest can exist and butt-raped with a broomstick by the idea of dignity inherent in simpler lives. Absurd, of course. But worth saving…on the off-off-off-chance that despite all evidence to the contrary, there is someone out there who’ll deserve and benefit from the elusive justice idealism lives to enable. Because his or her demise is a far greater injustice than all the ill-begotten victories of the assholes put together. So I’ll resuscitate that pathetic invalid, bandage its wounds, and have it live another day, keeping it alive on bare faith and defiance alone. It’s gnarled and broken and looks a little like an old Chinese Crested with conjunctivitis, but it’s goddamn splendid.










