Noun: American Winners. Opinion: Love.
Image credit: Sports Illustrated
It is election year. Politicians are telling us why America’s so great. Clint Eastwood is on a Super Bowl ad telling us why America’s so great. My friends, studying for their naturalization tests, are telling me why America’s so great.
The Judgmentor agrees. America’s so great. But I’m pretty sure we don’t all agree on why, and in a series of posts I’ll be investigating why I’m right and everyone else is wrong. Here are my credentials: I was born here, I didn’t always live here, I don’t always belong here, but I belong less everywhere else. I grew up in America, mostly, and was considered foreign. When I lived where I looked like everyone else, they considered me American. I don’t identify with any particular land or place, but I’m of a species that could only have evolved in the United States. I’m both insider and outsider at once, and I will identify Americans as “they” and “us” depending on my mood.
I love this stupid country. Here is the first of many reasons why, in a new series we call “The Judgmentor in America” (insert dramatic bass drum effects):
Americans are good winners: I came to know competition in a different world, an Asian world. There’s more at stake there in the outcome—the glory of victory is taken as a matter of fact, as a social achievement. The shame of loss is seen as a personal failure. It’s a method of promoting conformity and the rule of law while avoiding the blight of Western democracy: the race to the bottom, the curse of the average, the disgrace of the lowest common denominator. And it works, too, so you should work on your chopsticks skills because this prehistoric implement you call a “fork” is hard to pronounce for most of us, and we will likely rid of it when our superior math skills (even the girls) allow us to vanquish this society of creatures who are lazy, entitled, and as far as we yellow-types can discern with our slanty eyes, a bit undercooked and in need of a couple more minutes to brown in the wok.
For many years it never occurred to me that competition could be fun for anyone; it was supposed to be work and toil, punitive and fearsome. Americans’ delight in competing and fetishistic belief in competitive markets can come across as primeval; like Romans savoring the blood-seasoned air of the Colosseum, Americans revel in competition even when the game is rigged. Actually, that’s not entirely accurate—as opposed to the Roman indifference to the viable parity between a Christian and a lion, Americans care very much that the playing field be level. But this jock itch for sport and faith in capitalistic dogma can render Americans blind to systemic handicapping, which effectively takes the armor off the Christian and the muzzle off the lion. It somehow fails to register. Game on! Americans cry in their bloodlust. Game on! they cry, followed by attempts to mimic the howling of wolves.
To many in the world, this American excitability is a bit of a turn-off. I used to think so, too. But then I realized that Americans come to competition from a different angle than most—an angle unique to their unpretentious, uncomplicated natures. Americans love a clean game and a hard-won victory. Americans don’t love to lose, but they don’t hate failure as much as most; they’re sincerely glad to have played, those dopey sons of bitches. Americans, callow as they are, don’t see cheating as an evil necessity; they don’t even account for it when strategizing against the other team. And Americans don’t masturbate triumphantly when they’re on the winning side of a blowout; they’ll actually take it easy, take a knee, give the benchwarmers a chance to play, and be content never knowing how high the score could have gone. I’m not sure how to explain how amazing this is. I don’t know if I can convey how unique this is. This—is not the way it is in much of the world. This—is not what competition means in other places. This—is entirely disarming and adorable.
But the quality that completely redeems Americans of their caveman-like belief that to-take-one-must-club-over-the-head is how well they behave when they win. They’re usually good losers, but when I think of American competition nothing comes to mind as clearly as the Olympics and in the Olympics, Americans win a whole hell of a lot. And there are a lot of opportunities there to be obnoxious about it, but growing up I didn’t see many who took them. Most of the narratives were along the lines of the Miracle on Ice, a little before my time but utterly indicative of my ultimate point, when the Americans beat the undefeated Soviets in a medal-round hockey game. It was the winter of 1980. 52 Americans are held hostage in Iran. We’re a solid generation and a half into the Cold War. We’re still twitching from whatever Agent Orange-drenched shrapnel embedded itself into our collective skull in Vietnam. Those Soviet bitches just invaded Afghanistan, which was decidedly not cool. The late 1970s saw the birth of this strange phenomenon of mass school shootings, an inauspicious sign of American self-inflicted violence to come. Inflation was high, unemployment was high. It was a time of uncertainty and confusion in America. It was a time when America had real enemies out there, ones our own size, ones we were afraid of. It was a time when America had real conflict at home, ones we created, ones we were afraid of. It was a time when Americans weren’t really feeling like winners.
The Soviet team was expected to win. The American team was expected to lose. There would be lots of good reasons to lose, and people would comfort each other with those reasons when we lost, and though it would feel real fucking groovy to beat those pinkos, shit man, you dig? Well, never mind. Let’s hope we play a good game.
I can never follow the puck in hockey, making it a really boring sport of men randomly skating in a rink with the occasional eruption of nonsensical brawls and loss of teeth, but from what I can gather the game basically went like this: the Soviets come out humping hard, the Americans face the assault nobly until the end of the first period when they get a lucky shot, tying up the game. The Soviets, like all heroes in Greek tragedies facing an inevitable end, presumably grunt at each other and shrug it off, not realizing the import of this turn of events. They’re winners, remember, and have the muscle memory of winning, so come out grinding even harder in the second half. American goalie Jim Craig bites his lip and takes it like a power bottom. A little more back and forth, a defensive error, Americans are up with twelve minutes to kill, the Soviets flail and go limp, with five seconds to go broadcaster Al Michaels asks if you believe in miracles, answers his own question (“Yes!”), the entire USA hockey team comes spilling out onto the ice and fall on top of one another like a litter of golden retrievers deliriously happy to be a puppy in a world made of puppies.
There’s a lot more homoerotic hugging and skating, then the two teams line up to shake paws, and the camera closes in on the hero of the hour, Craig. And this is the moment that feels somehow different, special, and very American. Craig wasn’t exactly known for being easy-going or modest, but this moment speaks volumes about him and the American winner. He’s standing there like a groom at a receiving line. He’s shaking his opponents’ hands and nodding at them, like he’s acknowledging what they look like without their helmets on. It’s not rushed, it’s not reluctant, there’s no undertone of smugness or conceit. He’s friendly but not smiling too much, he’s looking into their eyes, he’s pleased to see them there, thanks for coming. Good game, good game, let’s grab a beer sometime, good game, that was a good shot you got by me, good game. And he’s doing all this while experiencing the BIGGEST BONER OF HIS LIFE. And you know he’s got a stiffy because after he’s shaken the last hand he ejaculates an enormous smile with his arms up while doing a little leap of joy.
That right there is an American winner.
There’s a lot of decency and humility that goes into being able to do that. There’s a lot of respect for your opponent and generosity towards others. That there is the kind of moment your papaw was trying to prepare you for when he talked about the importance of character.
And the Russians were stunned, of course. They were disappointed, of course. But good winners have a way of bringing out good losers, and they smiled back when the Americans smiled at them. Good winners know that the win mattered because the opponent was worthy, and when good winners celebrate they invite the losers to the spoils. Even if they’re Soviets. It’s only right.
I’ve seen more good winners born in America than anywhere else. It makes me feel OK about their weird competitive streak, their strange need to compete for competition’s sake, their penchant for making more work for themselves. It’s mostly benign. I still don’t love the game, whatever the game is, and I don’t much care who wins, but I do and will always love a good winner. Good winners are the best this country has to offer when it is at its best—good winners are what we get when we do it right and well at the same time.
Good winners are also becoming increasingly rare. Is it just me? I don’t recall winners of my youth gloating. I don’t recall dancing in the end zone, as if struck with a neuromuscular disease. I don’t recall people going out of their way to rub their opponents’ noses in the shit they just took in their mailbox. Good winners don’t do that. Good winners enjoy their victories but not at the cost of someone else’s pride and hard work. If your team won the Super Bowl and you heckle the wife of the opposing quarterback, even if she is a bag of bitch and crazy, you’re not a good winner. If you’re rich and have contempt for the poor, you’re not a good winner. If you are lucky and privileged and think you’re a better person because of it, you’re not a good winner. If you’re part of the majority and exploit the minority, you’re not a good winner. That’s not what good winners do.
And as far as I’m concerned, that’s not what good Americans do.
America is the last natural habitat of good winners, species benus victorius bigbonorum americanus, and they are highly endangered. Please help protect this species. They are hugely important to our environment.






